Tuesday, February 22, 2011

More on the Value-Added Tax - An Alternative to Sales Tax?

Earlier Chris Berrens posted on the value-added tax (VAT). I also felt compelled to expound on the VAT due to its relevance to sales tax and global prominence. As Chris mentioned, most of the rest of world utilizes the VAT as seen by the dark-shaded countries in the map below (updated 2008).


The VAT differs from a sales tax, in that instead of taxing a good at the point of sale on the consumer, the product is taxed along the production line as value is added to the product as demonstrated in this graphic.



So while most of the rest of the developed world has utilized this popular form of taxation, why hasn’t the U.S. opted for this policy? It is generally considered to be very feasible with low administrative costs and is also quite adequate at raising sufficient revenue (Source). This New York Times article also finds the VAT to be better than equivalent sales taxes for two key reasons:

First, if a single business evades the value-added tax, the government does not lose a large portion of money, because it will collect taxes at other stages of production.

Since companies usually get credit for taxes already paid by their suppliers, companies will pressure other businesses in the production chain to prove they paid their taxes. That means the system is somewhat self-policing.

The VAT does not go without criticism however. As with sales tax, there are equity issues with the regressiveness of the VAT. Similar to the way Minnesota exempts clothing and unprepared food from sales tax, many countries using the VAT exempt similar items to make the tax less regressive (Source). Other countries, such as Australia, combat the regressive aspect by having an aggressively progressive income tax (Source).

Despite its pros and cons, the VAT’s biggest hurdle to being used in America is likely the political feasibility. As mentioned in class, the cost associated with switching to such a system may be prohibitive or at the very least unpopular. Additionally it appears that the VAT’s own popularity (especially in Europe) may even be working against it. Back in November, the then-prospective House majority leader, Eric Cantor dismissed the potential of implementing a VAT, commenting: “I don’t think any of us want us to go the direction of the social welfare states around the world.” I’ll let Paul Krugman respond.

Friday, February 18, 2011

The Property Tax Refund and LGA

There is an implicit agreement between the State of Minnesota and its cities and counties. They (cities and counties) will use property taxes to gather revenue, so that the State can use sales and income taxes. There are some exceptions, where cities have to get permission from the legislature in the form of a bill, to levy a sales tax to pay for capital improvements. Two examples are: 1) the percentage tax in downtown bars in Minneapolis to cover expenses on the Metrodome, which is still being levied almost thirty years later, and 2) the Hennepin County sales tax to pay for the Twins Stadium.

Cities have only been able to increase property taxes to make up for the reduction in aid. The restrictions on taxation, based on initial agreements between cities/counties and state governments has made the LGA cuts even worse for low income, property owning citizens. LGA is meant to equal disparities between cities and counties across Minnesota. If LGA did not exist, the tendency would be higher for people to live in areas with lower taxes near those with higher services and taxes, such as Dr. Zhao's Ypsilanti/Ann Arbor example.

If cities such as Saint Paul and Minneapolis raised revenue from sales and income taxes it would cause an imbalance in the funds available to the places where people tend to live, such as the suburbs, but the cities would have a larger operating budget. Alternatively, cities such as New York Mills, South Haven, or Glencoe might have lower property values and a small enough population that they can't raise the minimum funds from that tax base to provide basic services.

Besides LGA, the property tax refund (PTR) has the greatest benefit reducing disparities to low income residents, especially where taxes are higher, such as the metro regions across Minnesota. However, the property tax refund has been significantly reduced over the past ten years. This has only compounded disparities in taxation, and exacerbated the foreclosure crisis by reducing help to property owners most likely to need tax reductions to help pay their mortgages.

The graph to the left shows the growth in both residential homestead property taxes and a lower trending homeowner property tax refund (primarily meant to offset income disparities) from 1975 to 2008. The scale for taxes illustrated is ten times that shown for property tax refunds. Total refunds have decreased in real terms since 1975, when total refunds of $82.6 million equaled $330.5 million in 2008 dollars after adjusting for inflation. The graph below shows how property tax aids and credits from the State’s General Fund have generally been reduced over the past 10 years.
Source: 2010 MN House Research Department


Who Bears the Burden?

Our class discussion and readings for this week focused on the much hated and often debated property tax. Part of what we asked was, "Is Minnesota's property tax regressive?"

The 2009 Minnesota Tax Incidence Study is conducted every two years by the Department of Revenue to find out just who pays Minnesota taxes. Using 2006 data, the report explores who bears the burden of state and local taxes. So, what did they say about property taxes?

The study shows that in 2006, the effective property tax rate ranged from 7% for the first population decile (households making $9,782 or less) to 1.3% for the top decile (households making %123,939 or more). Holy moly, that's regressive!

Fortunately, Minnesota Property Tax Refunds (PTR) are intended to decrease the tax burden on seniors, people with disabilities, and low to moderate income earners. The PTRs are referred to as Circuit Breakers when they apply to homeowners and Renters Credits for renters. After accounting for these returns, the effective tax rates ranged from 4.2% for the first decile to 1.3% for the top decile. In fact, these returns help make the overall tax system in Minnesota less regressive; they decrease the Suits index from -.075 to -.053.

So who benefits from the PTR? The Minnesota Budget Project points out that in 2007, nearly 600,000 households benefited from the returns. Slightly under half of the beneficiaries were renters and the rest were homeowners. Seniors and people with disabilities made up a significant percentage of those who received both the Circuit Breaker and Renters Credit, 38% and 28% respectively.

Property taxes place a disproportionate burden on low to moderate income households in Minnesota, but the Property Tax Refunds help to lighten the load.

Interactive: The Chopping Block


Yet another budget "game," this time on the Federal expenditure level:

http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/2011/02/budget.html




Special Service Districts

As John’s post below shows, “Special taxing districts” are some of the fastest growing levy increases in recent years. Much of this is a response from local government to deal with increased demand for public services, deteriorated infrastructure, and plans for economic development, transportation, and safety. Much is also due to the ability for cities to utilize unique MN laws that allow for the creation of independent governmental units for defined areas “within the city where special services are rendered and the costs of the special services are paid from revenues collected from service charges imposed within that area.” (MN Statute 428(A)) These districts provide special services that are typically not provided by general-purpose governments (*note: these are different from special school district levies/taxes)

Local examples abound: the Metropolitan Mosquito Control District, Metropolitan Council (with 10% of its funding through property taxes), and recently examples of hyper-local Special Services District (SSDs) like the Minneapolis Downtown Improvement District (DID), which actually collects taxes and runs the district as a separate nonprofit organization - with its own private vendors, contractors, staff, and processes. See DID map at http://assets.ngin.com/attachments/document/0015/1407/Zone_8.5x11.pdf.

In SSDs, a defined geographic area is assessed additional property taxes for services of their choosing – from entire neighborhoods to commercial corridors, to even specific street intersections. (the example below is the Riverview Theater intersection)

Minneapolis has 16 current districts in many neighborhoods. Many new areas (including Cedar Riverside) are looking to implement a variation of a SSD for capital improvements, safety zoning, marketing, and “clean and green” initiatives.


Next time you travel through the Hennepin-Lake-Lagoon Ave area of Uptown Mpls, or Downtown, look around – you’ll notice that there isn’t snow blocking sidewalks or parking meters, abundant bicycle parking loops and pedestrian benches are installed and clean, and there may be a nice string of lights through the trees, shrubs, and distinctive lights on the boulevard. These things were paid by property owners in the area as additional property tax, as these are all over-and-above what the city normally provides for a streetscape and maintenance.

Property owners in current SSDs generally favor the enhancements and additional services because they can see directly what their money pays for - although the business owner usually pays for the tax indirectly through the lease agreement. As budgets for local government services dwindle and increased public-private partnerships become necessary, could this model be used to provide common services (that government ordinarily would provide) through more tangible fee-for-service taxes?

Thursday, February 17, 2011

Decreasing Increases in Property Taxes

It’s no secret property taxes have been going up. After the cuts in recent years to state-funded LGA (Local Government Aid), property taxes have risen by 3.2% in 2010, 5.6% in 2009 and an average of 6.9% for years 2008-2010. The Minnesota Department of Revenue estimates that for every $1 cut in aid, property taxes increase by 67 cents. As shown below, the biggest increases have been levied by the special taxing districts.



So my question is if property taxes have increased an average of 6.9% per year between 2008-2010 but only 3.2% in 2010, what has made the increases decrease? Did Governor Pawlenty substantially increase LGA in the final years of his term? Not quite. In 2008 a state law was passed putting a cap on increases in property taxes. The legal limit is the lower of a)inflation or b)3.5%. Last year (2010) it was calculated by inflation: 0.8%. Special levies for debt, public safety and certain other costs are not subject to the cap. (Source: MN Dept of Revenue) So property tax increases are shrinking but last year’s 3.2% is obviously well over the .8% cap. How can this be? This is because any jurisdiction over 500 residents exceeding the cap must hold a Truth-in-Taxation hearing where residents have greater input over the proposed budgets. For example, in 2010 the overall statewide city portion of property taxes was initially proposed with a 5.4% increase but the final increase was only 4%. (Source: League of Minnesota Cities) One would have to assume the Cap and the Truth-in-Taxation hearings have had an impact. Is this law a good thing? I’m sure local government leaders don’t like them as they are under more public pressure. So in short, the state has cut aid to local governments while restricting their ability to make up the difference. Perhaps with Governor Dayton in office whose newly released budget proposal makes no further cuts in LGA, the need to raise property taxes will diminish; or will it considering the budget must clear a Republican house and senate?

Buy vs. Rent

Here is an interesting interactive map that describes which cities have a home price structure that is more favorable to renters or homeowners. I thought it was applicable for our conversation about the incentives that people have to own a home. Just click on the image.

State Budget Primer Video

Whiteboard video primer on the state budget from TPT and Commissioner Schowalter. Click here.

Property Tax Assessment

In class we discussed the process of assessing property tax and more specifically the assessment methods and quality of assessment. Assessment can be costly to a government agency which is why many do property assessment annually or biannually, such as Minneapolis. According to state law, the value and classification of real estate are established as of January 2 and December 1 each year for Minnesota.

What, you may ask, are the conditions they assess? Some discussion around assessors examining only the exterior and not considering the interior of a home came about during class. According to the City of Minneapolis "assessor's base the estimate of market value on the characteristics of the property that affect market value such as size, age, condition, and basement finish, as well as special features like fireplaces, extra baths, walkout and other factors." The assessed market value is then compared to market sales "to assure property values are fair and equitable." Property classification such as commercial, apartment, farm, homestead are also considered with market value in property tax assessment. Do you live in Minneapolis? Curious about your estimated property tax? The City provides a Property Tax Estimator.

After an assessor has come to your home the assessor mails a value notice by the end of March each year indicating the value and classification of your home for property taxes you will pay the following year. Did you know that if you disagree with your value notice you can call the appraiser and discuss your concerns? If even after your discussion with the appraiser you feel that your assessment is incorrect you can appeal your assessment.

How many people do you think actually go through this process to be sure their property is assessed fairly?

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

State Budget Crunch Affects Property Taxes

State budget cuts can affect property taxes at the local level. Minnesota's complex system of state aid (known as Local Government Aid, or LGA) is allocated to local governments on a complicated need-based formula, and local governments plan for and budget these funds as revenue sources. In recent years, state legislators and governors have reduced the amount of LGA that is distributed to solve budget problems at the state level; this can create budget problems for local governments, who have planned to receive certified amounts of LGA. (You can see how much cities are certified to receive in 2011 here) .

The Minnesota Department of Revenue has estimated that "every dollar the state cuts in LGA causes a 67 cent increase in local property taxes" . It seems that local governments make up some of the lost revenue by raising property taxes, which makes sense - citizens demand certain services, so it would be very challenging for local governments to completely absorb the LGA cut without some additional revenue.

Today, Governor Dayton released his budget proposal for the next biennium. In his proposal, Governor Dayton proposes no cuts to LGA and other aids to local governments. Since the governor ran on a platform of "tax the rich," it may not be surprising that he proposed a new income tax bracket for the state's top earners. However, there's another interesting element to his proposed changes to the Minnesota tax structure: a statewide property tax on homes valued at more than $1,000,000. Currently, Minnesota has a statewide property tax on business properties and recreational properties like cabins; adding a statewide property tax on homes over $1,000,000 would be a significant change.

A press release from Governor Dayton notes that his "budget represents [his] values and priorities," and also claims that property taxes are "the most regressive and unfair of all state and local taxes." We've talked about considering taxes based on four concepts: efficiency, equity, adequacy, and feasibility. In his press release, Governor Dayton seems to argue that the property tax fails on several of these main criteria. An argument could be made that property taxes may not be efficient or equitable, but that they do score points on the adequacy and feasibility measures. For example, property taxes can raise sufficient revenue, addressing the adequacy measure, and property taxes are currently in place in many local governments and are probably not extremely difficult to administer, addressing the feasibility measure. What do you think?

Sunday, February 13, 2011

While increases in the amount of property taxes a homeowner must pay can be attributed to either a rise in tax rates or increases in property values, the abysmal level of home values in this economic climate clearly show that the higher amount of property taxes that Minneapolis homeowners must pay this year are due to an increase in the rate of taxation –a whopping 6.5% increase in property tax rates. Where will most of this tax revenue go? Pension funds, with the largest recipients being the Minneapolis Police Relief Association, the Minneapolis Fire Relief Association and the Minneapolis Employees Retirement Fund. This puts Minneapolis as the second highest for property tax increases in the state, though still behind Rochester, whose residents will see an 8.4% increase this year. The chart below shows the highest city levy increases in Minnesota cities with over 50K population this year:



Our readings for this week mention that many states require truth-in-taxation procedures when there are increases in the amount of property taxes that citizens must pay – whether due to an increase in property values or changes in the tax rates (pg 324). So were Minneapolis residents forewarned or allowed to weigh in about the proposed property tax rates? Yep. The state of Minnesota, through Minnesota’s Truth in Taxation policy, requires that local government entities provide public advertisements on the budget/levy of certain taxing jurisdictions, parcel-specific notices sent to the owner of the property, public hearings and changes in the property tax statement when such increases occur. Here is the truth in taxation bulletin from the City of Minneapolis concerning the increase.

A public hearing was also held in November 2010 in regards to the tax hike, though I couldn’t find any minutes from the meeting. I was however able to find minutes from a Truth-In-Taxation hearing in Nobles County (MN), showing that there weren’t any citizens present at the meeting. I wonder if the Minneapolis hearing was any different.

As a Minneapolis homeowner, I wanted to know which county had the lowest tax rate…turns out that Dakota County has the lowest county property tax rate in the Twin Cities metro area and the state in general. See the chart below for comparisons with other counties in the Twin Cities metro area, and here for information on how it is the lowest in the state. Despite these tax increases, I still value access to public transportation, walkability, the arts, events and city-life too much to "vote with my feet" and leave Minnapolis/Hennepin County...at least for now!




Saturday, February 12, 2011

Wish we could do that over

Back in 2009, the City of Chicago signed a contract leasing control of its 36,000 parking meters to private firm owned by Morgan Stanley. The deal, set to last 75 years, netted the city $1.15 bllion in upfront revenue which was a significant windfall in comparison to the roughly $19 million generated by the meter system annually.

The deal drew harsh criticism from all sides. Not only was the plan announced and made law almost overnight, but many believed that the low asking price and long contract amounted to nothing more than intergenerational theft.

At the time, however, cash was desperately needed. Chicago was facing a budget deficit of $169 million, and it was projected to balloon to $400 million by the following year. And some believed that the Chicago parking meter deal was a win-win situation and marked the dawn of a new era in the P3 (public-private partnership) world.

Two years later, however, the deal is looking more like a payday loan. The government initially used part of the $1.15 billion to close the budget deficit and then set the remainder aside in what it called a “Rainy Day Fund.” Now, the money set to last for 75 years is almost gone, with only $76 million left, and no revenue stream appears ready to take its place. Furthermore, recent reports indicate that Morgan Stanley will earn more than $11 billion over the next 75 years as a result of the contract.

Chicago’s budget deficit in 2010 now stands at just over $650 millionwith mayoral candidates offering no shortage of new proposals—such as building a city casino—as ways to close the gap. In the end, this series of events seems to reinforce the discussion about incentive-driven budgets. Politicians want to keep services and lower taxes, while residents want more for less.

After years of deficits, it seems that the residents have noticed the writing on the wall. A new Chicago Tribune poll found that citizens see service cuts as a way to balance the budget. But it’s anyone’s guess when those preferences will manifest themselves in the city’s budget.

By Jay Willms

Value Added Tax?

As our class has shown us, budgeting offices all over the country are probably running out of red ink. The country faces a number of tough decisions over the coming decades on how it chooses to deal with a series of pressing fiscal questions. There are a number of challenges that we face from an aging population to large trade deficit. These issues are making the call for a revamped tax structure louder and louder. Many are now calling for a value added tax. It does basically what it says, every time someone adds value to a product (Making wood into a table) it gets taxed.

The value added tax is used by nearly every single developed country on Earth, except for the U.S. These countries like it because the management of a value added tax is relatively easy. Members along the supply chain hold each other accountable to paying their share so that one entity doesn’t have to pay all tax obligations. However, there are a lot of people that don’t like it because the structure can be quite regressive as it is a consumer driven tax. In left leaning circles this problem is addressed by lowering income tax obligations on lower wage earners to offset the potential downside.

People on both sides of the political isle agree that our tax system is in desperate need of an overhaul. The tax code has gigantic loopholes that incentivize organizations to spend time and energy finding ways to reduce their tax obligation. It prevents companies from competing equitably with one another in the market. Our overall tax structure is one of the lowest in the world but the graph below shows that we are simultaneously taxing business investment at a high rate. This can reduce incentives for companies to invest, which can be quite inefficient towards driving economic development (Graph below). A value added tax could help drive innovation by removing barriers to entry brought on by poor taxing structure, but potentially raise new concerns.


Friday, February 11, 2011

Tax Structures, The World Around

Grappling to find a tax structure that generates adequate revenue, but also reflects social values without over burdening the economy, is a tall order for any government. As is the case here in the United States, most countries around the world surely struggle in weighing the pros and cons associated with various systems of taxation.

In New Zealand, the leader of the Labour Party is proposing adjustments to his county's tax system, that would eliminate the goods and services tax (GST) on fresh foods, among other things, and make up the revenue difference by increasing the income tax rate on the country's highest earners. The following link provides an argument against the measure and addresses some of the concepts that we've discussed in this week's class.

http://www.odt.co.nz/news/business/146059/tax-plan-would-harm-system

Minnesota, Donor State

This past week we discussed the various avenues of revenue collection at different levels of government, and how to evaluate taxes in terms of equity and adequacy. A perusal of the Minnesota Dept. of Revenue site provides great context. Between 1849 and the Great Depression, the state relied heavily on property taxes to fund public services. During the economic hardship, state coffers dwindled, so individual and corporate income taxes were adopted in 1933. As the chart (below) shows, reliance on property taxes has eased up and now the state enjoys a fairly balanced tax cocktail.


The folks over at D.C.-based TaxFoundation.org – with their mandate of promoting public tax awareness – have charitably amassed a minor treasure trove of interesting information regarding taxes in Minnesota. Their comparative studies reveal the relatively large burden levied against Minnesotans in particular at the State and Federal level. We are, it turns out, a donor state, with $40.6 billion paid to D.C. in 2005 versus $31.1 billion received. This is contrasted with a state like, say, New Mexico, which paid $9.9 billion in the same year and received $20.6 billion. I hear the weather is really nice in Santa Fe.

Apparently I’m not the only one. A glance at Minnesota’s net migration numbers shows that an estimated $31.7 million in taxable income (about 1,000 households) migrated from Minnesota to New Mexico between 2000 and 2008. Of course, "The Land of Enchantment" is not the biggest culprit. Florida netted $1.4 billion, Arizona netted $664 million, and Wisconsin netted $398 million. But it’s not all bad. We took $303 billion from North Dakota. All told, Minnesota saw a net departure of 30,000 households representing a loss of $2.9 billion in income.*

The numbers don’t necessarily imply that people are moving in order to avoid taxes. Minnesota may have a high average tax rate (compounded by a double taxation of business real estate, e.g. all of downtown Minneapolis), but it is important to remember that Minnesota is also very nice. Despite complaints from certain well-funded member organizations.

This does help highlight certain aspects of vertical and horizontal tax systems (dare I say Euclidean tax systems?) which retain revenue stability despite a mobile population. It is intriguing, though, to see federal tax/federal funding imbalances being paralleled by population outflows. The explanation possibly lies with the movements of retirees. More on this subject as time permits.

*All figures adjusted for inflation (in 2009 dollars).

Short Term Instability vs. Long Term Externailties

Theory suggests that the most economically efficient and least disruptive way to raise revenue is to tax those items where there is a low level of elasticity, specifically, necessities like food and clothing as opposed to luxuries like jewelry and limousines. While it may provide more stability in the short run, over the long run, the effects of externalities may prove such a policy to be misguided.


The problem lies in the price of eating healthy. Even in the status quo, healthy foods are comparatively expensive. The New York Times reported in December 2007 that the price of “unhealthy” food was $1.76 per 1000 calories, whereas the price of “healthy” food was $18.16 per 1000 calories.


A nutritious diet for any given person means that they will, over the long run, keep in better health, thereby increasing their personal and the economy’s productivity. This means higher tax revenue for governments, increased productivity for their employer, higher wages for the person, and lower health care costs to society vis-à-vis Medicare and/or Medicaid.


If a tax were to be placed on food, we would end up creating a long-term health problem due to substitution effects: as the price of healthy food increases, this would cause a number of people who would otherwise consume healthy foods to instead choose unhealthy food, as healthy food would no longer be economically viable for them. The positive long-run externalities that would have otherwise been captured by individuals and society would therefore be lost.


Taxing necessities such as food may be advisable in the short run to avoid disruption to the market, but, over the long run, their effects on consumer choices may prove such taxes to be unadvisable.

Minneapolis Convention Center Revenue Sources

A recent City of Minneapolis report outlines the current financial health of the Minneapolis Convention Center and the ongoing provisions used to support the facility. The center relies heavily on operating revenue (i.e. space rental), a citywide sales tax, and several taxes targeting downtown consumption patterns. In 2009, the revenue breakdown was as follows:


Convention Center Revenue (in millions)

2009

0.5% Citywide Sales Tax

$26.5

3.0% Entertainment Tax

$9.1

3.0% Downtown Restaurant Tax

$9.9

3.0% Downtown Liquor Tax

$3.8

3.0% Lodging Tax

$5.7

Operating Revenue (space rental)

$13.4

Total

$68.4


As we begin to discuss tax analysis, the convention center serves as an interesting case for evaluating tax equity. If the convention revenue system is to rely on consumption taxes, the taxed goods and services appear to be selected with at least some care for non-convention goers. However, the taxes are clearly not immune from imposing unnecessary burdens. Most of the selected taxes affect anyone going downtown to a show, restaurant, or sporting event - whether they are attending a convention or not.


However, one must examine the intended benefit of the convention center to determine if the taxes actually impose an unnecessary burden on non-convention goers. The City report states that the convention center was created to “foster and generate economic growth and vitality by providing facilities and services for conventions… which benefit the City, the metropolitan region, and the State of Minnesota” (p. 140). Funds also support the operating expenses for Meet Minneapolis, a non-profit that books convention center events and markets the Twin Cities as a convention and tourist destination. So, is the tax bundle really a ‘civic image’ tax? If so how can we measure the benefit the City receives?


A Star Tribune article states that 70% of convention goers in 2009 lived within the Twin Cities metro area. Is the building really fulfilling it’s role as a marketing tool if it is only attracting local residents? Still, it terms of economic development, the same article estimates that the center generated $173 million for the local economy in 2009. However, a 1994 study projected that same figure would be closer to $300 million, raising questions of the taxes’ adequacy during difficult economic times.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Kick the Can: Considering the Soda Tax

Governments at all levels are looking under their collective couch cushions for every penny they can find. Creative revenue generating ideas range from taxing pornography, to building racinos, to (legalizing and then) taxing marijuana. These are all variations on the tried-and-true “sin tax” formula.


A family friendly, PG version of a sin tax idea has been recently kicked around in the form of a soda tax. The U.S. Senate considered the tax in 2009 as a way to help pay for President Obama’s health care initiative. Both the Mayors of New York and Philadelphia as well as New York Governor David Patterson sought soda taxes in recent budget proposals.


On the surface, the soda tax idea is a good one: Offset the costs of healthcare programs with the tax, while simultaneously battling the obesity epidemic. It’s roughly the same justification for the steep rise in cigarette taxation in recent years. One could make the argument that, in fact, the nation’s obesity epidemic is of a greater public health concern than are the impacts of smoking.


But, the issue isn’t so clear cut. Is the soda tax justifiable when there is no essential nexus between the tax and the programs it supports? If the soda tax revenue is simply funneled into a state’s general fund, is it still justifiable on public health grounds?


What of a state budget that purports to use the funds for health care programs, but also makes cuts to those same programs in the same budget, as this article points out? What if the soda tax did not actually reduce soda consumption, as some studies claim that it would not?


Considering that a sales tax is regressive, and considering that some studies show that the poor tend to consume more sugary beverages than the average citizen, wouldn’t the brunt of the tax fall disproportionately on the poor? Is the tax equity issue enough to undermine the purported health benefits?


The soda tax debate is representative of the type of dialogue we're likely to see in the coming months as Minnesota looks to fill its 6.2 billion dollar revenue gap with new and creative funding sources.


Please, anything but a pizza tax.

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Federal taxes lower under Obama than under Bush

This post from Slate today has a great quote from a former Bush administration advisor:

"America's tax system is clearly broken...It fails at its most basic task, which, lest we forget, is raising enough money to pay for the federal government."

Monday, February 7, 2011

Obama's 2011 Budget Proposal: How It's Spent - Interactive Graphic


Super interesting graphic breakdown of Federal Budget spending:



Friday, February 4, 2011

Public Choice Through Mobility

I have serious misgivings about the use of mobility as a solution to political problems.

The concept of public choice through mobility (or voting with your feet) is generally credited to the American economist Charles Mills Tiebout (1924-1968). In his influential 1956 article, A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures, Tiebout puts forth mobility as the solution to problems that voting at the local level generally do not solve. Mobility purportedly solves the free-rider problem and the problem that many voters do not have their tax and service preferences satisfied.

Even if one assumes all of Tiebout’s assumptions hold, the outcome would degrade democracy. Tiebout sorting would homogenize society into groups of like-minded individuals, destroying the notion of the common good and the act of collective deliberation. The Tiebout model ignores the fact that society is made of people we disagree with, yet must deal with in a civilized manner. To simply sort people into like-minded groups also denies the fact that members of a society must acknowledge some level of responsibility to one another. Perhaps no one in recent political dialog has voice this sentiment more eloquently than President Barak Obama, when he said “If there is a child on the south side of Chicago who can’t read, that matters to me, even if it’s not my child”. In a world where like-minded people have sorted themselves into a group that devalues education, that matters to the rest of society, but not to the believer in Tiebout sorting. If you believe in the Tiebout model, as long as the group is getting the service they desire, at a price they are willing to pay, all is well. This notion transforms citizens into what Tiebout calls consumer-voters, whose decisions are considered sovereign. But consumer sovereignty is a troublesome idea when it is extended from the marketplace into the public square. Consumers often make bad individual (and usually selfish) decisions, while democracy (hopefully) produces better decisions and admits some level of selflessness and civic virtue.

For an excellent examination of political philosophy and justice, see Justice with Michael Sandel.



Minnesota considers expanding state sales tax

If you haven't heard, Minnesota is confronting a major budget shortfall. Legislators are debating how to restructure revenue and expenditures to balance the state budget.

28.6% of Minnesota's general fund tax revenue comes from the state sales tax. This morning's Star Tribune included a lengthy article about the potential expansion of the state sales tax. Talk is about expanding the reach of sales tax, not raising the sales tax rate. Currently, food, clothing, and most services are exempt from sales tax.

Interestingly, expanding the sales tax to food, clothing, and services could raise enough revenue to cover the state's $6.2 billion budget deficit. The MN Department of Revenue estimates the potential sales tax revenue to be $7.5 billion for FY 2012-2013. This breaks down to:
  • Groceries: $1.5 billion
  • Clothing: $639 million
  • Services: $5.4 billion
Problem solved, right? But as we discussed in class, sales tax is considered a regressive tax. Low and middle income households spend a higher proportion of their income on goods and services. Also, many of the services that would be taxed are legal and professional services provided to businesses as inputs to their final products (which are then taxed again when purchased by the consumer).

Naturally, grocers, the Mall of America, lawyers, and advertising agencies are opposed to sales tax expansion. What do you think?

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Economic Mobility and Externalities

In class we've discussed several times the importance of mobility on both markets and the policies of the various levels of government. Each level of government can be seen as generating and regulating unique externalities. At times, to either the benefit or detriment of the other levels, as well as other countries. Examples abound:

The federal government enjoys the positive externality of an overall more intelligent and skilled populace by having more lax immigration policies towards non-citizens that have advanced degrees or special skills - enabling a brain drain (undoubtedly a negative externality) to be suffered by other countries that in some sense supplied that skilled person to the labor market. See Immigration and Nationality Act.

Laws enacted by states that uniquely benefit their own citizens, while diverting negative externalities to other states are struck down. See Kassel v. Consolidated Freightways Corp.

Some municipalities, in order to prevent the negative externality of concentrated poverty due to clustered affordable housing communities, are required to provide an amount of affordable housing proportionate to the need of their community. See NAACP v. Township of Mount Laurel.

Fiscal federalism provides an overview of the externalities put on the different levels of government, as well as individuals, through government budgeting. The priorities that one level of government adopts and actualizes will result in another level sitting back, holding off on those same priorities - enjoying the benefits without taking on the costs. This works the best, however, when the level actualizing the priority (usually through money) is the more inclusive level (federal as opposed to state, county as opposed to city). This provides some logic to the U.S system that provides the bulk of tax revenue to the federal government, allowing those funds to generate externalities that benefit local governments.

Externalities, LGA & Paul Wellstone

The readings and class discussion this week focused on the conditions that, from an economic perspective, require government intervention or service provision. The issue of "externalities" is particularly interesting in the context of the current budget debate here in Minnesota and the Local Government Aid (LGA) program.

Chapter two from Fisher's text states, "If consumption or production generates benefits for others that are not considered, then the consumer or producer underestimates social benefits and chooses too little of that economic activity." In my view, there is currently a severe underestimation of the social benefits Minnesotans derive from their own city's services, and this is even more true when it comes to services provided by cities hundreds of miles away.

Why should someone who lives in Eden Prairie care about the livability and tax burden in Minneapolis? The reasons primarily relate to externalities.

One reason is that the odds are very good that an Eden Prairie resident will travel into Minneapolis for work or for entertainment and expects a certain level of street maintenance and public safety services along the way. This is why "commuter burden" is an externality accounted for within Minnesota's Local Government Aid formula (the "accidents per capita" factor).

A more removed yet often cited rationale is public safety -- that if large metropolitan core cities are allowed to deteriorate and crime rates rise, the crime rates of surrounding first- and second-tier suburbs are likely to rise as well.

But why should that Eden Prairie resident care about the livability and tax burden in Hallock -- a very small city in the far northern reaches of the state? Especially if they've never been there and don't see any reason why they ever would?

The externalities are more...external...but still very much exist. A good quality of life in small cities means families with children will still live there. Small businesses will remain there and generate revenue utilized in their local community, their region, and the state.

The alternative (and an increasing likelihood for small LGA-dependent cities) is a deteriorated quality of life. If left unrectified, low quality of life leads to shuttered main streets and ripple effects to the other businesses that once supplied them. Neighborhoods filled with vacant housing, attracting crime and drug activity that spills over to nearby regional centers.

The fact that Minnesotans rarely stop to think about their interdependence allows state officials to underestimate the value of intergovernmental revenue sharing without substantial political consequence -- at least in many parts of the state.

And unlike state funding for K-12 education, which nearly everyone has had direct experience with and understands the value of, programs like Local Government Aid are not well understood by the general public and are therefore easily mischaracterized and maligned -- and with a $6.2 billion state budget hole to fix, more easily cut. Just today, the State Senate voted on its first budget-balancing bill of the session and it includes a massive reduction in Local Government Aid. The underestimated social benefits of this program have led to a choice to reduce this particular economic activity.

The interconnection among Minnesotans is more real and more impactful than any of us can really get our heads around. But the underlying concept is simple and perhaps best summed up by the quote often attributed to Paul Wellstone, "We all do well, when we all do well."

Madison's Nightmare: How Much Should We Spend for National Insecurity? - The Atlantic

This article discusses how the United States Defense budget compares to others across the globe. It touches on some survey question (similar to the discussion on 2/2) used to measure the public's perception of DoD's spending. It also gives a nice discussion and definition of Budget Authority.

Enjoy!

Madison's Nightmare: How Much Should We Spend for National Insecurity? - The Atlantic