The course weblog for PA5113, State and Local Public Finance, at University of Minnesota
Showing posts with label Development Impact Fee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Development Impact Fee. Show all posts
Wednesday, April 17, 2013
Problems with Exactions and Impact Fees
Exactions and impact fees have been useful tools for local government to help finance services as demand for services increases with growth. While impact fees may be exacted for any type of impact (air pollution, park use, expanded fire protection, etc.), the most common application of impact fees is to levy them for increased road and water/sewer demand that accompanies new development. Despite their usefulness in generating revenue, the administration of exactions and user fees contains some critical flaws that diminishes the overall utility of this tool.
The main problem with user fees is that they do not fully account for the life-cycle and replacement costs of the infrastructure that they create. While they are often designed to give municipalities initial capital funds or at least enough financing to procure a bond (thus allowing city officials to say yes to developers and grant them the permits they are requesting), exactions and user fees don't account for the life-cycle costs of the infrastructure that they finance, and eventually, cities must tap into their general tax revenue to pay for the expansion in infrastructure. For areas with higher service delivery costs (i.e. far away from existing infrastructure), this can turn into an expensive proposition.
A second problem is the "nexus" legal framework that asserts that there must be a reasonable connection between infrastructure need and new growth. In practice, this has prohibited cities from using impact fee revenue for projects that may have more benefit to their municipalities, and instead must be used for expenses related to the new growth. Towns looking to revitalize infrastructure in other neighborhoods or fund items like expanded public transit with impact fee revenue will be unable to meet the "nexus" legal test and have these efforts stymied, as the funds must be spent on the new growth. The "nexus" framework helps to drive the growth machine by taking away cities' ability to choose which projects get funded, and only must fund the new projects with impact fee revenue (thus, the older infrastructure in out-of-fashion neighborhoods takes longer to receive attention or gets neglected entirely, reinforcing reinforcing the logic of the vicious circle of greenfield growth and old-neighborhood abandonment).
The cost and supply of new services for growing communities is not fully accounted for by impact fees and exactions. Cities must maximize the effects of density and find ways to more effectively incentivize infill and denser development, so that they can enjoy the efficiencies that come from agglomeration. The "nexus" test makes generating this type of momentum more difficult, but a concerted effort by policymakers (regional government entities, such as Minnesota's Metropolitan Council, could play a critical role) towards greater density will help us rein in our infrastructure expenses and make for more efficient local governments.
Saturday, March 12, 2011
Are Development Impact Fees Legitimate?
According to 59% of cities and 39% of counties, yes [1]. Development impact fees are one-time charges applied to developers in order to offset the additional public-service costs associated with new development. Fees can be used to build water and sewer systems, roads, schools, libraries, and parks & recreation facilities, made necessary by the presence of new residents in the area [2]. However, the fees must have an essential nexus to the development at hand—they cannot arbitrarily be used for city infrastructure not directly related to the development [3].
The central idea behind development impact fees is that new developments should pay for what they cause or use, thus, relieving the tax burden placed on existing taxpayers. As stated in the University of Minnesota Center for Transportation Studies report, "...it is generally accepted as appropriate that all developers, regardless of their scale, should help bear the cost that their developments impose on the community."
Development impact fees in Minnesota have been rare, in part because state law neither allows nor prohibits the use of development impact fees, leaving them in legal limbo [4]. The primary reason cities avoid them, it seems, surrounds their legal legitimacy and the number of judicial challenges to them. One particularly interesting case in the Twin Cities area occurred in 1997, when Country Joe Inc., a contractor, challenged the City of Eagan's road connection fees [5]. Other similar cases are numerous [6].
Should Minnesota start using impact fees more regularly?
Yes.
Advantages of development impact fees include user equity, reduced municipal borrowing, controlling urban sprawl [7], and promoting proactive planning [8].
No.
Disadvantages of development impact fees include greater burdens on and less supply of affordable housing [9] (i.e., since developers redistribute the fees to the development, it increases the market price per unit), intergenerational equity issues (i.e., new vs. existing residents), and a complicated administrative process [10].
The current state of impact fees....
Due to the current economic downturn, many municipalities are considering reducing or eliminating development impact fees to encourage development, especially if the development will create more affordable housing and jobs [11]. Will that decision work? Ed McMahon, a senior resident fellow at the Washington, D.C.-based Urban Land Institute, believes reduced impact fees will not translate into increased development activity. “I don’t think these rollbacks will produce much new development. The reason development is not taking place has little, if anything, to do with development impact fees,” McMahon says. “It has to do with the marketplace; it has to do with the lack of financing [12].”
One must also consider whether or not eliminating development impact fees is a sustainable approach to managing a city. Are cities encouraging leapfrog development, thereby jeopardizing our natural resources? And the larger question.... what is the financial cost to the city if development impact fees are eliminated?
By Jill Townley
The central idea behind development impact fees is that new developments should pay for what they cause or use, thus, relieving the tax burden placed on existing taxpayers. As stated in the University of Minnesota Center for Transportation Studies report, "...it is generally accepted as appropriate that all developers, regardless of their scale, should help bear the cost that their developments impose on the community."Development impact fees in Minnesota have been rare, in part because state law neither allows nor prohibits the use of development impact fees, leaving them in legal limbo [4]. The primary reason cities avoid them, it seems, surrounds their legal legitimacy and the number of judicial challenges to them. One particularly interesting case in the Twin Cities area occurred in 1997, when Country Joe Inc., a contractor, challenged the City of Eagan's road connection fees [5]. Other similar cases are numerous [6].
Should Minnesota start using impact fees more regularly?
Yes.
Advantages of development impact fees include user equity, reduced municipal borrowing, controlling urban sprawl [7], and promoting proactive planning [8].
No.
Disadvantages of development impact fees include greater burdens on and less supply of affordable housing [9] (i.e., since developers redistribute the fees to the development, it increases the market price per unit), intergenerational equity issues (i.e., new vs. existing residents), and a complicated administrative process [10].
The current state of impact fees....
Due to the current economic downturn, many municipalities are considering reducing or eliminating development impact fees to encourage development, especially if the development will create more affordable housing and jobs [11]. Will that decision work? Ed McMahon, a senior resident fellow at the Washington, D.C.-based Urban Land Institute, believes reduced impact fees will not translate into increased development activity. “I don’t think these rollbacks will produce much new development. The reason development is not taking place has little, if anything, to do with development impact fees,” McMahon says. “It has to do with the marketplace; it has to do with the lack of financing [12].”
One must also consider whether or not eliminating development impact fees is a sustainable approach to managing a city. Are cities encouraging leapfrog development, thereby jeopardizing our natural resources? And the larger question.... what is the financial cost to the city if development impact fees are eliminated?
By Jill Townley
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)